Is foreign currency debt the right answer for FX hedging?
- August 31, 2018
Hedging and Capital Markets
Private Equity | London
Using debt as a natural FX hedge by matching it to the company’s EBITDA currency split, is a commonly deployed solution in private equity. For example, a EUR-reporting business, generating half its EBITDA in EUR and half in USD, would draw debt in these same proportions.
Both banks and debt fund lenders will in many cases offer the borrower the choice to redenominate term loans in whole, or in part, into a different currency with no margin differential. This makes redenomination quite attractive as it neatly addresses FX exposures — and back in 2014 or 2015, when interest rates were not too dissimilar in EUR, USD, and GBP, there was little difference in funding costs across these currencies. However, this has changed significantly as interest rates across the major currencies have materially diverged: three-year USD swap rates are close to 3% but for EUR they are only 0%. Assuming a lender charges a margin of 6% over the three-month LIBOR in both USD and EUR, redenominating from EUR into USD increases the annual interest rate bill by 50%.
"Before deciding to denominate debt in a foreign currency, it is important for any company to have thought about the impact on the P&L."
An additional drawback of having foreign currency debt on the balance sheet is its impact on the company’s P&L, as it needs to be re-measured into the reporting currency at the spot rate on each reporting date. That introduces P&L volatility, albeit below EBITDA. Before deciding to denominate debt in a foreign currency, it is important for any company to have thought about how address this issue — whether by applying hedge accounting (if possible); neutralising the P&L volatility by hedging with derivatives; or simply accepting the impact.
Does this mean that redenominating debt should not be considered if the interest rate differential is too wide between the currencies in question? Matching EBITDA and debt from a currency perspective can also stabilise leverage ratio and, more importantly, equity value. These benefits may outweigh the increase in funding costs and potential P&L volatility. This assessment, however, hinges significantly on the company’s exact currency position, which drives how volatile leverage ratio and equity value would be if one didn’t match debt and EBITDA.
To complicate matters further, it is also possible for a company to manage its currency exposure using a derivative-based strategy, for instance in the form of a cross-currency swap or other FX hedge. Depending on the business objective, this may be a more or less attractive alternative. Considerations in pursuing this solution include credit line availability, the pricing offered by derivative providers and potential P&L impact.
What should borrowers do?
It is hard to generalise, as the answer is dependent on so many different variables. Provided that the objectives are well defined and the right questions are asked, one can explore the various alternatives and make an informed decision. Unfortunately, heuristics may not cut it anymore.
Contact the author
Please complete the form below to find out more about the topics discussed in this article.
This material has been created by Chatham Financial Europe, Ltd. and is intended for a non-U.S. audience. Chatham Financial Europe, Ltd. is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority of the United Kingdom with reference number 197251.
Our featured insights
Treasury teams face a new landscape for 2021, which impacts forecast certainty, capital structure, and priorities. Companies are evaluating budgets, cash needs, and automation to drive efficiency. This session will outline areas to address now to prepare for managing financial risk in 2021.
We will provide a blueprint for maximizing the return of your FX hedging program by using data-driven decisions to set up an effective program, increasing operational efficiencies, automating manual processes, streamlining accounting workflows, and communicating meaningful reporting to stakeholders.
A case study of how Chatham advised Capital Economics to optimally hedge the FX exposure from a multi-currency revenue stream and cost base.
On November 26, Chatham Financial accepted the inaugural Hedging Adviser of the Year award at the 2020 Risk Awards. This new award recognizes excellence in providing independent advice to derivatives users.
Our annual business review summarizes JCRA's (now part of Chatham Financial) and Chatham's European activities, sector trends, and deals in 2019.
Read our analysis on how best to hedge FX risks and how we advise funds and businesses on optimal pricing for their FX transactions.
An FX option is a contract that confers on the holder the right but not the obligation to exchange an amount of one currency for another at a pre-agreed rate (strike rate) on or before a pre-agreed date.