What will your swap actually cost at closing?
Hedging and Capital Markets
Real Estate | Kennett Square, PA
Interest rate swaps are one of the tools that commercial real estate (CRE) borrowers can use to manage the risk associated with floating-rate loans. Borrowers choose to purchase swaps with the rationale that they are “free”, especially when compared to an interest rate cap that typically requires an upfront payment. However, swaps are certainly not free, and can have a significant cost if not negotiated carefully.
What fee is that, you might ask? We are talking about the swap fee, credit charge, or mark-up. It goes by many names, but it is ultimately the overhead and profit that a lender embeds into the swap rate in excess of the mid-market swap rate. The mid-market swap rate, which reflects a swap provider’s cost, is the rate at which two credit-worthy banks would transact if one wanted to pay fixed and the other wanted to receive fixed in the same swap structure. The fixed rate that a real estate borrower agrees to pay in a swap is the combination of this mid-market rate and the credit charge the bank will add to the rate at execution.
How does this happen? Don't lenders have to disclose all of their fees?
Let’s consider an example. A bank issues a term sheet for a floating-rate loan at SOFR plus a loan spread, say 2.00%. The term sheet states that the borrower will be required to swap the floating rate to a fixed rate of interest and that the current all-in rate would be 4.30% (this all-in rate is equal to the 2.00% loan spread plus the fixed swap rate). On the surface, this rate may seem fair. But what is not disclosed is the fee that the bank plans to embed in the swap. If the bank’s mid-market swap rate is 2.00%, they have added a 30-basis point fee to the swap rate. On a $25M, 7-year loan this amounts to a present value cost to the borrower of about $500,000. Dodd-Frank requires banks designated as swap dealers to disclose their mid-market swap rate at the time a swap is entered into, but not when a term sheet is provided to a prospective borrower. This means that in our example, a borrower may only learn at closing that the bank is charging 30 basis points on the swap. Of course, it’s probably too late at that point to question a swap fee of 30 basis points, at least without delaying the closing.
As mentioned, Dodd-Frank requires swap dealer banks to disclose their mid-market swap rate at swap execution. But they will tell you (and it’s true) that the Dodd-Frank mid-market swap rate does not accurately reflect their cost to provide the swap. A swap is a credit-intensive product, and as such, there is a cost for a bank to face a real estate borrower. Chatham models thousands of trades every month-end, and for many of them we calculate a Credit Valuation Adjustment (CVA) that takes into account the potential for losses due to a counterparty default. The CVA that we calculate roughly reflects a bank’s cost to provide a swap. For a SOFR + 2.00% borrower, this cost is typically 5–10 basis points on a 7-year swap. The additional swap fee (20–25 basis points in our example above) goes to cover the cost to maintain a derivatives desk and, of course, to profit.
What can you do?
We know that reliable access to real estate debt capital is the lifeblood for most of our commercial real estate clients. What can be done that won’t damage your lending relationships? First, discuss the credit charge for any swap with potential lenders before you sign a term sheet, and ask them to disclose it in the term sheet. You can tell them that you are trying to assess the whole picture of the proposed loan before making a decision, and that the swap credit charge is important in that analysis. Agreeing on a swap credit charge, expressed in basis points, will allow both parties to know what the all-in loan rate will be even as the underlying mid-market swap rate fluctuates between term sheet signing and closing. While this does not prevent the rate from potentially rising during this time, you will know the final rate you pay is what you negotiated upfront.
You take into account all the fees, expected interest costs, proceeds, covenants, and prepayment characteristics when selecting a lender, right? Don’t leave out of your analysis what could be the biggest fee of all!
To learn more about interest rate swaps, contact Chatham's real estate team.
Chatham Hedging Advisors, LLC (CHA) is a subsidiary of Chatham Financial Corp. and provides hedge advisory, accounting and execution services related to swap transactions in the United States. CHA is registered with the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) as a commodity trading advisor and is a member of the National Futures Association (NFA); however, neither the CFTC nor the NFA have passed upon the merits of participating in any advisory services offered by CHA. For further information, please visit chathamfinancial.com/legal-notices.
Transactions in over-the-counter derivatives (or “swaps”) have significant risks, including, but not limited to, substantial risk of loss. You should consult your own business, legal, tax and accounting advisers with respect to proposed swap transaction and you should refrain from entering into any swap transaction unless you have fully understood the terms and risks of the transaction, including the extent of your potential risk of loss. This material has been prepared by a sales or trading employee or agent of Chatham Hedging Advisors and could be deemed a solicitation for entering into a derivatives transaction. This material is not a research report prepared by Chatham Hedging Advisors. If you are not an experienced user of the derivatives markets, capable of making independent trading decisions, then you should not rely solely on this communication in making trading decisions. All rights reserved.
Our featured insights
The intrinsic value of interest rate caps
The upfront costs of interest rate caps have increased significantly in the past six months as short-term rates have risen and expected payouts on these caps have increased in probability and amount. This piece analyzes how cap pricing in the USD interest rate market factors-in expected future...
The Bank of England base rate hits a 13-year high
On 5 May, the Bank of England (BoE) voted six to three to raise the U.K. base rate by 0.25% to 1.0%. The last time the base rate was at this level was February 2009, when monetary policy was aggressively loosened to combat the effects of the Global Financial Crisis. The market reacted to the hike...
FOMC: accelerating rate hikes
On Wednesday, May 4, the Federal Reserve Board voted unanimously to raise the Federal Funds rate by 50 basis points to 0.75 – 1.00. This is the first time since 2000 that the Federal Reserve Board has raised rates by 50 basis points. They also outlined their balance sheet runoff plan which is set...
Liability management for housing associations
This piece is the first of a short series of thought pieces on how rising interest rates may impact housing associations' approach to managing treasury risk and funding. We look at the challenges and opportunities created for the debt portfolio, with a particular emphasis on organisations that...
With pending rate hikes, interest rate caps set to pay to CRE borrowers
With the Federal Reserve set to raise rates this week, and the market pricing in additional increases in June and throughout the remainder of this year, base rates like SOFR and LIBOR are likely to rise in lockstep. If these hikes occur as predicted, many interest rate caps will begin paying out...
The hairy chart: Historical accuracy of LIBOR forward curves
These hairy chart graphs plot past LIBOR forward curves against the actual path LIBOR followed, showing that the forward curve has been a somewhat accurate predictor over the next six months or so...
Understanding recent changes in SOFR-based loan index rates
There has been a recent divergence between the different variations of SOFR used in commercial real estate (CRE) loans, with Term SOFR increasing while daily simple SOFR and New York Fed 30-Day Average SOFR remaining relatively flat prior to the Federal Reserve meeting and the other starting to...
Central bank decisions in Europe – March 2022
The Monetary Policy Committee met last week and voted eight to one on a bank rate increase by 25 bps. The messaging behind the statement however tempered the market’s expectations for the extent of future rate rises in the U.K. The European Central Bank also met the week before and their policy...