Freddie Mac asks borrowers to extend protection on LIBOR-indexed ARMs through June 2023
Hedging and Capital Markets
Real Estate | Kennett Square, PA
U.S. bank regulators are asking banks to discontinue offering LIBOR-indexed loans and hedges (including caps and swaps) by the end of 2021. Borrowers may no longer be able to purchase/extend LIBOR caps they otherwise would have to extend beyond 2021. Freddie Mac is asking its Optigo lenders to encourage their borrowers to extend existing LIBOR caps or purchase additional cap coverage until at least June 30, 2023, the expected discontinuation date for LIBOR. Because this is a request and not a mandate, Chatham has prepared this update for clients who are weighing this guidance from Freddie.
In November 2020, U.S. bank regulators issued a statement providing that, with few exceptions, banks may no longer offer new LIBOR-indexed loans or hedges (including interest rate caps and swaps) beyond the end of 2021. Freddie Mac requires floating-rate borrowers purchase interest rate caps to establish a ceiling on their interest expense for the first few years of the loan (typically 2–3 years) and then to extend the cap before it expires (typically for 1–2 years at a time). Concerned about the possibility that LIBOR protection will not be available or less liquid after the end of this year, Freddie Mac encourages borrowers to extend their existing LIBOR caps through July 1, 2023, the anticipated discontinuation date for LIBOR. Freddie provided this guidance to its network of Optigo lenders on July 21, with the following key takeaways:
- Freddie is asking servicers to encourage borrowers with existing LIBOR-indexed ARMs to extend the LIBOR caps hedging these loans through the earlier of the loan maturity date or at least July 1, 2023.
- Freddie is encouraging borrowers to execute these extensions as soon as possible — no later than the end of this year. They view this approach as a best practice given the risk that LIBOR caps won’t be available beyond this year-end.
- SOFR caps would be available on LIBOR loans only in situations where a borrower chooses not to extend a cap now, and LIBOR caps later become unavailable.
- While Freddie has communicated its intent to its servicers, their services have not yet communicated this to borrowers; letters from some servicers to borrowers are expected to start going out as early as this week.
- Borrowers will be able to use funds previously escrowed for cap extensions if they elect to extend caps now. We are awaiting guidance from Freddie on how new escrow requirements will be calculated if an early extension is purchased.
Subscribe for weekly Agency cap pricing.
Considerations and recommendations
As this is a recommendation, not a mandate, Freddie Mac borrowers have a choice as to whether to extend any LIBOR protection now (potentially in advance of when a cap would need to be extended pursuant to loan requirements) or wait until the current cap maturity date. In evaluating this decision, we suggest factoring in the following considerations:
- Freddie Mac preference: While not a strict requirement, Freddie has articulated that it is their preference to see borrowers take this approach to avoid situations where a borrower is unable to extend a LIBOR cap and are forced to purchase a SOFR cap to cover a LIBOR-indexed loan. While the SOFR cap market is less liquid than the LIBOR market, SOFR caps have been readily available since Chatham executed the first Freddie Mac SOFR cap in September 2020.
- Asset plan: While plans may change, if a borrower plans to sell or refinance an asset prior to the current cap’s maturity date, they may be less inclined to extend the interest rate cap now.
- Additional extensions: Extending a cap early, through at least June 2023, may increase the number of cap extensions a borrower would need to complete. Consider a situation in which an existing cap expires in January 2023 and the borrower expects to refinance by January 2024. Absent this guidance, the borrower would likely extend the existing cap once in January 2023, through January 2024. Were the borrower to follow Freddie’s guidance, the borrower would extend the existing cap today through at least June 2023 and then again (with a SOFR cap) in July 2023, incurring transaction costs twice.
- Pricing considerations: As in any other situation where a borrower is considering extending an interest rate cap in advance, there is a trade-off between locking in a known price for the cap extension today or waiting until later when the term of the purchased cap is shorter and potentially less expensive. Consider a situation where a borrower has a $30M loan covered by a LIBOR cap with a 2.5% strike that expires on July 1, 2022, and will need to be extended for one year on that date. They could elect today to extend the cap for the additional year, purchasing the second year of a two-year cap today for a price of $19,000 based on current market conditions, locking in the cost. Alternatively, they could wait until July 1, 2022. If rate conditions don’t change and a LIBOR cap is available in the market, they will pay less for the cap — a spot-starting one-year cap with the same structure currently costs $10,000. However, if rate expectations or volatility increase, they may end up paying more than if they had extended the cap earlier. This should be a primary consideration for the typical Freddie borrower. If pricing today for an extension through July 1, 2023, is reasonable, then a borrower may prefer to extend the cap now. If the borrower is inclined to pay the minimum amount possible (and is willing to risk that pricing may move against them), they may prefer to defer the extension until closer to the required extension date.
- Basis risk: Freddie’s concern that LIBOR caps may be unavailable after the end of 2021 may be well founded, depending on how dealers interpret U.S. bank regulators’ guidance. In discussions with Freddie-approved cap providers, four have told us that they currently think it’s unlikely they’ll offer LIBOR-indexed caps in a meaningful way beyond end of 2021. However, the largest provider (by Freddie caps outstanding) has told us they are still evaluating whether they will continue to offer LIBOR caps beyond 2021. We expect to have clarity on this within a few weeks. Borrowers would be able to purchase SOFR caps on LIBOR loans if LIBOR caps are unavailable, but this introduces basis risk, the possibility that LIBOR will increase in a way not reflected by a commensurate increase in SOFR. In such a situation, a borrower’s interest expense on their LIBOR loan could increase while the SOFR cap may not provide the intended protection, causing the borrower to pay more net interest than if they had used a LIBOR cap. In most market conditions, this would be unusual — LIBOR and SOFR have a high degree of correlation as both tend to move in tandem with the Fed Funds target rate. However, in times of market distress when credit conditions are tightening, we do observe that LIBOR can temporarily spike relative to SOFR, as happened at the outset of COVID (see the period of March-April 2021 in the graph below). This risk is mitigated by the fact that most Freddie Mac caps have strike rates that are well out of the money compared to current rates. LIBOR would have to rise substantially (both absolutely and relative to SOFR) for this to drive a real economic impact for a borrower. Situations in which LIBOR has risen relative to SOFR by a meaningful amount, have tended to be relatively short lived. This consideration may be less significant for the typical Freddie Mac borrower.
With the possibility that LIBOR caps and cap extensions may not be available beyond the end of 2021, Freddie Mac is asking borrowers to consider extending LIBOR caps now through the anticipated LIBOR sunset date in mid-2023. Borrowers weighing this guidance should consider the import of Freddie’s stated preference, as well as underlying asset plan, the pricing of extending a cap now vs. later, and potential basis risk between LIBOR and SOFR in a situation where a borrower is forced to hedge a LIBOR loan with a SOFR cap. Please reach out to Chatham with questions as you weigh these considerations.
Speak to a Chatham expert
Please reach out to the Chatham team if you have questions about how the LIBOR transition could impact your loans and derivatives.
Chatham Hedging Advisors, LLC (CHA) is a subsidiary of Chatham Financial Corp. and provides hedge advisory, accounting and execution services related to swap transactions in the United States. CHA is registered with the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) as a commodity trading advisor and is a member of the National Futures Association (NFA); however, neither the CFTC nor the NFA have passed upon the merits of participating in any advisory services offered by CHA. For further information, please visit chathamfinancial.com/legal-notices.
Transactions in over-the-counter derivatives (or “swaps”) have significant risks, including, but not limited to, substantial risk of loss. You should consult your own business, legal, tax and accounting advisers with respect to proposed swap transaction and you should refrain from entering into any swap transaction unless you have fully understood the terms and risks of the transaction, including the extent of your potential risk of loss. This material has been prepared by a sales or trading employee or agent of Chatham Hedging Advisors and could be deemed a solicitation for entering into a derivatives transaction. This material is not a research report prepared by Chatham Hedging Advisors. If you are not an experienced user of the derivatives markets, capable of making independent trading decisions, then you should not rely solely on this communication in making trading decisions. All rights reserved.21-0208
Our featured insights
Understanding recent changes in SOFR-based loan index rates
There has been a recent divergence between the different variations of SOFR used in commercial real estate (CRE) loans, with Term SOFR increasing while daily simple SOFR and New York Fed 30-Day Average SOFR remaining relatively flat prior to the Federal Reserve meeting and the other starting to...
Interest rate swap FAQs for CRE investors
These frequently asked questions address some of the common issues that commercial real estate borrowers face when considering an interest rate swap. These include swap rates and mechanics, prepayment/breakage, and documentation.
GBP LIBOR’s last days, SONIA, and the start of synthetic GBP LIBOR
With only days to go until the final GBP LIBOR fixing, below is a short update on current state of transition and the emerging discussions on use of synthetic LIBOR.
Understanding LIBOR alternatives in CRE loans
Commercial real estate (CRE) lenders have begun to adopt SOFR and other LIBOR alternatives, presenting borrowers with different variations of these rates. This overview provides a summary of the common permutations of these rates and borrower considerations for each.
Hedging costs update — November 8, 2021
The Fed has started tapering its purchase of bonds, signaling a potential end to quantitative easing (QE). This has occurred in the context of a market that has pulled forward expected timing for a rate hike from the Fed. These factors have driven a rapid increase in hedging costs, particularly...
The finish line is in sight — GBP LIBOR transition
As the date for the final GBP LIBOR fixing nears, the work from the banking and advisory community to transition all outstanding contracts from LIBOR to the new RFR is gathering momentum. We have previously published articles on the background to the transition and how borrowers should prepare....
U.S. real estate and capital markets update Q3 2021
As we wind down on summer 2021, many Americans are returning to the office and sending their children back to school. We recently reviewed the effects of COVID-19 on the U.S. economy and takeaways for the real estate market during our semiannual market update webinar. On September 15,...
European real estate and capital markets update Q3 2021
It’s back-to-school month for most children, and back to the office for an increasing number of workers too. What better time to host our semiannual market update webinar for real estate? On 15 September, participants listened to our experts, Adrian Ng and Jamie Macdonald, provide an overview of...