Competing for loans in a low-rate environment
- October 13, 2020
Head of Sales
Financial Institutions | Kennett Square, PA
Challenged by having excess liquidity and fewer loan opportunities, financial institutions need to utilize all available tools to be competitive and determine how best to meet their customers’ needs while also managing their own rate risk in this historically low-rate environment.
Many financial institutions are dealing with the dual impact of having excess liquidity and limited loan growth due to the ongoing pandemic. The growing cash balances, which were sought after in late Q1 and early Q2 as a safety net for a rapidly changing market, have become a challenge to utilize and are pressuring earnings. Loan growth generally has been slowing since May, and most securities offer minimal yields without taking additional credit, duration, or optionality risk.
In the commercial loan arena, many borrowers are looking for long-term fixed-rate financings to take advantage of the historically low yield curve. With fewer loan opportunities available in the market, financial institutions need to be competitive and think about how best to meet their customers’ needs while at the same time managing their own rate risk. There are three proven interest rate hedging strategies that can be used to help both parties meet their objectives.
- Offer borrower swaps
The bank provides its borrower with a floating-rate loan along with a pay-fixed swap to achieve a fixed-rate financing. The financial institution can then enter into an offsetting swap with a dealer bank to eliminate the rate risk. This structure is commonly referred to as a “back-to-back swap” and can also result in upfront fee income recognition for the bank. It’s typical to see swap fees in the 25-35 basis point range which can quickly become meaningful as many banks try to diversify their revenue mix.
- Hedge fixed-rate loans
The financial institution provides its borrower with a traditional fixed-rate loan and utilizes a swap with a dealer bank to manage the rate risk. The swap can start at inception or have a forward effective date to allow the bank to maintain a higher initial yield which could be especially important in this low NIM environment. The only impact on the fixed-rate loan to the borrower is that it would need to include “make-whole” language to be consistent with the swap in the event of a partial or full prepayment.
- Hedge fixed-rate loan pools
Rather than swap individual loans, the bank could aggregate fixed-rate borrowings and apply a macro hedge. The institution would create a closed pool of prepayable fixed-rate loans and hedge a portion of the pool based on a prepayment analysis. This structure is commonly referred to as a “last of layer” strategy and has become very popular given more flexible accounting rules. Similar to loan-level hedging, the bank could use a spot or forward-starting swap to achieve its preferred mix of fixed and floating-rate exposure.
There are over 400 community and regional banks using one or more of these hedging strategies to compete for new commercial loans. For those financial institutions that are considering these types of interest rate risk management tools, it can feel like a steep learning curve to get started. It’s important to first partner with a trusted advisor that is independent, transparent, and experienced. An advisor should be able to assist with training all stakeholders and completing the key implementation items. Additionally, an advisor can provide ongoing support with trade structuring, pricing execution, hedge accounting, and regulatory compliance.
During challenging times like these, financial institutions should be utilizing all available tools and resources to better compete for attractive lending opportunities. There are a variety of interest rate hedging strategies that can be effectively used to meet the specific needs of banks and their borrowers in this historically low-rate environment.
We'd like to hear from you
Learn how your financial institution can stay competitive with interest rate hedging strategies.
Chatham Hedging Advisors, LLC (CHA) is a subsidiary of Chatham Financial Corp. and provides hedge advisory, accounting and execution services related to swap transactions in the United States. CHA is registered with the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) as a commodity trading advisor and is a member of the National Futures Association (NFA); however, neither the CFTC nor the NFA have passed upon the merits of participating in any advisory services offered by CHA. For further information, please visit chathamfinancial.com/legal-notices.
Transactions in over-the-counter derivatives (or “swaps”) have significant risks, including, but not limited to, substantial risk of loss. You should consult your own business, legal, tax and accounting advisers with respect to proposed swap transaction and you should refrain from entering into any swap transaction unless you have fully understood the terms and risks of the transaction, including the extent of your potential risk of loss. This material has been prepared by a sales or trading employee or agent of Chatham Hedging Advisors and could be deemed a solicitation for entering into a derivatives transaction. This material is not a research report prepared by Chatham Hedging Advisors. If you are not an experienced user of the derivatives markets, capable of making independent trading decisions, then you should not rely solely on this communication in making trading decisions. All rights reserved.20-0398
Our featured insights
Powell reaffirms commitment to accommodative policy stance
Despite the expectation of additional fiscal stimulus and dovish comments from the Federal Reserve chair, the major U.S. equity indices pulled back last week amid weak economic data, rising COVID-19 cases globally, and the continued emergence of new COVID-19 variants.
Democrats gain control of Senate, U.S. Capitol protests gain global attention
The major U.S. equity indices marched higher on the week, setting fresh all-time highs, as Democratic Party victories in the two Georgia Senate runoff elections gained the party control of the Senate fueling hopes for increased fiscal stimulus.
President Trump signs COVID-19 relief bill
The major U.S. equity indices ended the final week of the year on a high note, setting new all-time highs, as the passage of a federal stimulus bill and continued distribution of two COVID-19 vaccines in the U.S. dominated headlines and improved investor sentiment.
Credit unions: extending asset duration and managing rate risk
Credit unions have experienced a significant increase in member deposits during the pandemic which has led to excess liquidity and low-yielding cash balances. Hedging tools may help these institutions extend asset duration and improve margins while also managing their incremental rate risk.
Vaccine developments improve sentiment
The major U.S. equity indices ended the week mixed with the Dow Jones Industrial Average and the S&P 500 moving higher and the Nasdaq heading lower amid rapidly rising COVID-19 cases in the U.S., mixed economic data updates, and encouraging COVID-19 vaccine developments.
Indirect swaps: we’ve got control issues
See how introducing indirect swaps into the mix may seem simple at first, but can result in control issues for one of the bank’s greatest assets – its customers.
Community banks: adding lending tools to leverage PPP momentum
In a piece written for BAI, Matt Tevis highlights how smaller institutions are thinking about how they can retain and broaden their new commercial relationships.
2020 Back-to-Back Swap Program Benchmark Statistics Report
Interested in seeing how your interest rate swap program stacks up relative to your peers? Perhaps your financial institution is not yet using swaps to win more commercial loan business, but would find value in reviewing and analyzing Chatham's Back-to-Back Swap Program Benchmark Statistics Report.
The three C’s of indirect swaps
Ben Lewis writes for Bank Director and discusses the concerns that bankers need to consider when choosing to work with correspondent banks that offer indirect swaps to their borrowers.
Analyzing the economics of an indirect swap hedging program
The CEO of a community bank who actively offers indirect swaps to borrowers contacted Chatham and was looking to analyze pricing. They wanted better visibility into the economics of a $6.8M transaction the bank had recently executed.
LIBOR transition enters crunch time in 2021
Bob Newman discusses the transition away from LIBOR with S&P Global Market Intelligence.
Chatham structures and executes the first AMERIBOR interest rate swap transaction
Chatham Financial announced today that it has structured and executed the first AMERIBOR-indexed interest rate swap in a designated hedging relationship on behalf of First Merchants Bank.
Market Update: Strategies for Volatile Markets Q4 2020
Our experts examine the factors driving the markets and discuss the balance sheet risk management strategies being implemented by financial institutions. We will share perspective on the interest rate risk management concerns by reviewing the challenges and opportunities in today’s volatile market.
NCUA proposes changes to derivatives rules
The NCUA Board approved a proposed rule to modernize and simplify the agency’s derivatives rules. The proposed changes would make it easier for federal credit unions to use common hedging tools to manage their interest rate risk especially during these times of disruption and uncertainty.