Defeasance? Ask these questions.
SummaryDefeasance is the process through which a borrower is released from the obligations of their debt. This piece helps CRE professionals understand the questions they should ask before defeasing.
While the defeasance process can be summarized in a few lines, in practice it is very complex, involving a large number of parties with competing interests. Having an independent, experienced advisor on the borrower’s side is important to ensuring an on-time, cost-effective, and complication-free close.
Things to look out for when defeasing
- Has the defeasance consultant thoroughly reviewed the loan documents and provided a comprehensive defeasance analysis to the borrower?
- Are there ambiguous provisions in the loan documents that could result in value gained or lost by a borrower? If so, how will you approach negotiating them with the other parties involved?
- Have all anticipated third-party fees been fully disclosed to the borrower?
- What is the consultant’s fee structure? Is it reasonable?
- Will the consultant ask for a deposit? Chatham does not charge an upfront deposit for consulting services.
- Will residual value be generated as a result of the defeasance? If so, is the defeasance consultant returning a significant majority of this value back to the Borrower?
- Can the defeasance be structured to the early prepayment date, for a complete upfront savings on the last few months of interest?
- Is the loan subject to rating agency review which will entail additional time and cost?
- Will the securities portfolio include higher-yielding, lower-cost agency securities in addition to Treasuries, if applicable?
- How is the defeasance consultant going to purchase securities? Competitive auction or one relationship bank? A competitive auction utilizes the power of the marketplace to drive prices lower through competition.
- Has the defeasance consultant structured the most efficient portfolio possible? This is best achieved through a competitive auction, which typically results in the lowest all-in defeasance costs, even where a consultant may offer to reduce other fees.
- Have the changes in defeasance costs over the life of the transaction been reviewed?
- How much will defeasance costs decrease after every monthly loan payment?
- How will movements in Treasury yields affect defeasance costs?
- Is the loan currently eligible for defeasance? All CMBS loans are locked out for a period of two years following securitization. Some CMBS loans are subject to a yield-maintenance penalty instead of defeasance.
Common mistakes made by borrowers when defeasing
- Not budgeting enough time for the defeasance process
- Unknowingly accepting costs that are higher than market standard
- Failing to negotiate favorable defeasance provisions in new loans (for refinances) or Purchase and Sale Agreements (for sales)
Hiring an independent consultant is not only recommended, it's usually a critical piece to avoiding these mistakes and navigating the defeasance process without delaying loan closing.
Chatham Financial has executed over $148 billion total principal defeased and returned over $187 million in residual value to borrowers. Defeasance consultants are a part of Chatham's global real estate financial risk management practice, solving common but complex capital markets challenges for commercial and multifamily real estate investors.
Need help with defeasance?
Contact a Chatham advisor about defeasance or yield maintenance.
Our featured insights
Negative defeasance penalties return for the first time since 2006
Chatham Financial has executed several defeasance transactions with negative penalties this fall. Negative defeasance penalties occur when replacement Treasury yields exceed the loan’s coupon. This scenario allows commercial real estate (CRE) owners to exit their CMBS (Commercial Mortgage Backed...
Key takeaways: Semiannual Market Update webinar for real estate
On February 9, Chatham held our Semiannual Market Update webinar for real estate, presented by Matt Hoffman and Jackie Bowie. There was a macroeconomic update covering the U.S., U.K., and Europe, a discussion on hedging considerations and strategies, and a brief update on the IBOR transition. In...
When deciding to prepay your fixed-rate CMBS debt, whether through yield maintenance or defeasance, most borrowers have questions. Chatham routinely supports the majority of principal balance, including the largest individual loans, defeased in a given year. View Chatham's list of yield...
What is a successor borrower?
A successor borrower is an entity that takes on the payment responsibilities of the original borrower after a commercial real estate (CRE) loan has been defeased, often giving rise to “residual value” by virtue of the nature of the securities portfolio as compared with the loan being prepaid....
Capital markets and accounting considerations in real estate M&A
Mergers and acquisitions involve a multitude of complexities and risks. Speed and accuracy at every stage of an acquisition is critical to not only winning the deal but also giving the transaction the best chance of financial and strategic success. Financial risk associated with the valuation of...
Understanding yield maintenance
Both yield maintenance and defeasance allow borrowers to unencumber the underlying real estate asset. From a legal and economic perspective, the two processes are fundamentally different.
Defeasance best practices for borrowers, brokers, counsel
Successor borrower rights are a material defeasance consideration, not just at the time of defeasance but at loan origination as well. This provision is often negotiable at loan origination and can play out in a variety of ways at execution. Chatham routinely supports the majority of principal...
Financial risk management serving commercial real estate since 1991
Chatham Financial is the largest independent financial risk management advisory and technology firm. A leader in debt and derivative solutions, we provide access to in-depth knowledge, innovative tools, and an incomparable team to help mitigate risks associated with interest rate and FX exposures.