Purchase price allocations in times of uncertainty
Real Estate | Kennett Square, PA
SummaryThe purchase price allocation is a critical audit matter in accounting for a new acquisition. Amid a recession, the valuation of the land, building improvements, and leases in place of an asset requires abundant testing and reconciliation to ensure the conclusions reflect fair market value.
Despite challenging economic conditions, participants in the commercial real estate (CRE) market continue to evaluate acquisitions. Companies with historic cost accounting will need to prepare a purchase price allocation on newly acquired assets. Developing a supportable allocation amidst times of uncertainty presents unique valuation challenges, including a dearth of comparable evidence, displacement of market rates, and uncertainty of speculative cash flow assumptions.
A misallocation of value to tangible and intangible assets can result in material impacts to investor reports and may put the company at risk for a future impairment or cumbersome audit scrutiny. As a result, auditors have deemed purchase price allocations as one of their most critical audit matters. However, a thorough purchase price allocation can not only pass audit but help bolster support for a company’s internal underwriting and instill greater confidence in the financial reporting statements.
The following summarizes key areas of focus to ensure that a purchase price allocation appropriately accounts for current sentiment and behavior of market participants during times of uncertainty.
Reconciling transaction price with fair value
An important first step in preparation of a purchase price allocation is a full reconciliation of fair value to the transaction price. When markets are changing rapidly, the reconciliation will ensure that the dynamic inputs and key performance indicators of the analysis will ultimately be reflected in the forthcoming allocation.
Some important reminders on the overall transaction analysis:
- Document any concessions, earn-outs, or other value-related discussions that were impactful to the finalized deal terms
- Report on insights from brokers, deal teams, and other industry professionals to adequately support capital markets assumptions used in the analysis
- Evaluate how any assumed debt impacted the purchase price
- Prepare multiple valuation methodologies and reconcile with the purchase price
A thoughtful analysis of the overall transaction will yield valuable insights to the valuation of the individual assets and liabilities.
Land valuation in an environment with few sales
Material shifts in real estate pricing are not evenly distributed between land and building improvements. The two components will need to be evaluated independently.
In cycles of economic contractions, land valuations are often the first impacted. As demand weakens, development activity typically slows, and as a result, land transactions are far less frequent.
Traditionally, a “Market Approach” is used to determine the value of the underlying land of an asset. However, a dearth of comparable transactions and deals will make it difficult to support a conclusion using this approach.
Additional means of valuation support – such as brokers’ opinions of value, trend analysis, or use of an alternate methodology (e.g., development method) – will be critical in developing a reasonable and supported land value conclusion.
Building improvements impacted by economic obsolescence
An uprooting of market demand may result in economic obsolescence to the building improvements. Newly identified structural vacancy, oversupply, or other shifts in leasing demand for the asset may not justify a full replacement of the building improvements.
In a challenged environment, a cost approach – an analysis of replacement costs less depreciation – alone likely will not adequately reflect various economic factors impacting building value. Further, changes in soft costs, entrepreneurial rewards, and other development incentives may significantly disrupt replacement cost estimates.
An income approach, or “go dark” scenario, is an alternate method in estimating residual building value. A discounted cash flow is performed where the improvements are assumed to be vacant and subject to lease-up. A building value is then estimated after deducting the value of the land and contributory site improvements. This approach better reflects valuation impacts from external economic factors and should be performed in tandem with the cost approach.
Replacement cost of a lease in place, and other value considerations
Lease economics such as base rent, escalations, downtime, free rent, and tenant improvements are all factors in determining the fair value of a lease agreement. As tenants across all market segments have pushed for additional concessions, deferrals, or rent reductions, granular research into the leasing environment of the micro-market will be necessary to calculate appropriate lease replacement costs.
In the search for credit quality and income security, market participants may find additional intrinsic value in a lease agreement. For instance, a lease with a quality tenant – one that would not be able to be reproduced in today's shifted environment – may justify a premium beyond simply replacement cost. Conversely, a deterioration of tenant credit or other collateral may elevate the probability of default on the lease and correspondingly justify a discount to replacement cost.
While the replacement cost of the lease remains relevant, an appropriate purchase price allocation will need to also contemplate a tenant’s credit quality, ability to service their commitments, and how these factors may have impacted the purchase price.
How Chatham can help
In an environment of uncertainty, thorough documentation and expertise is key in supporting purchase price allocation exercises. If internal resources are constrained, engaging an experienced third-party professional can be advantageous in establishing credible valuations.
Chatham’s team of experts in real estate valuation, accounting, and technology work in tandem to produce comprehensive, transparent, and cost-effective fair value exercises. Chatham has access to proprietary transactional data and deal insights that are leveraged into each valuation, and technological tools that ensure a timely delivered analysis.
Chatham can help
Request a pricing matrix for your purchase price allocations
Chatham Hedging Advisors, LLC (CHA) is a subsidiary of Chatham Financial Corp. and provides hedge advisory, accounting and execution services related to swap transactions in the United States. CHA is registered with the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) as a commodity trading advisor and is a member of the National Futures Association (NFA); however, neither the CFTC nor the NFA have passed upon the merits of participating in any advisory services offered by CHA. For further information, please visit chathamfinancial.com/legal-notices.
Transactions in over-the-counter derivatives (or “swaps”) have significant risks, including, but not limited to, substantial risk of loss. You should consult your own business, legal, tax and accounting advisers with respect to proposed swap transaction and you should refrain from entering into any swap transaction unless you have fully understood the terms and risks of the transaction, including the extent of your potential risk of loss. This material has been prepared by a sales or trading employee or agent of Chatham Hedging Advisors and could be deemed a solicitation for entering into a derivatives transaction. This material is not a research report prepared by Chatham Hedging Advisors. If you are not an experienced user of the derivatives markets, capable of making independent trading decisions, then you should not rely solely on this communication in making trading decisions. All rights reserved.20-0432
Our featured insights
European debt valuation FAQs
Debt valuation is important for any entity required to report fair value. Historically, there have been different valuation policies, methodologies, and opinions making comparisons difficult and leading to inconsistency. To facilitate transparency and confidence in the valuation of institutional...
Request your Q2 2021 Average Market Credit Spreads report
The information presented in this report represents average credit spread conclusions segregated by property type and grouped by LTV for the quarter ending June 30, 2021. Debt mark-to-market had a slightly negative impact on equity fund returns in Q2 driven by spread compression in fixed...
Capital markets and accounting considerations in real estate M&A
Mergers and acquisitions involve a multitude of complexities and risks. Speed and accuracy at every stage of an acquisition is critical to not only winning the deal but also giving the transaction the best chance of financial and strategic success. Financial risk associated with the valuation of...
Debt valuation methodologies for financial reporting
Debt valuation has long been a topic of debate among entities required to report fair value. Because of varied interpretations of accounting standards, methodologies for valuing debt have ranged from simply reporting the remaining principal balance to an application of complex algorithms. This...
Volatility in the valuation of swapped floating-rate positions — a proposed solution
This paper demonstrates the shortcomings of the current market practice for valuing swapped floating-rate positions and proposes a solution that addresses why there should not be a meaningful valuation difference between fixed-rate loans and certain swapped floaters.
Valuation of properties under development
NCREIF’s Valuation Committee has provided guidance on a common question we hear from our clients: “When should I recognize entrepreneurial profit in the valuation of properties under development?”
EPRA earnings and the requirement for debt valuation
Recent changes in the EPRA NAV measures have led many CRE borrowers to include a valuation on their debt portfolios. The following commentary summarises the changes, and how Chatham is assisting clients in this valuation and reporting process.