Positioning firms for resilient financial performance
Chatham Financial and Moody's Analytics partnered together on this white paper to review how firms can position themselves for resilient financial performance in any rate scenario, and covers topics such as interest rate risk, CECL, and hedging.
- Rising rates threaten key financial ratios of firms holding fixed rate loans and debt securities portfolios
- Accounting changes diversify strategies that qualify for hedge treatment, more fully reflect risk management strategies in financial results
- CECL tools provide a stochastic, multi-scenario view of interest rates, credit and prepayment behavior—critical inputs to hedge strategy and effectiveness
After decades of low interest rates, many financial institutions find themselves with long-dated, fixed rate assets in a rising rate environment. In periods of rising rates, it is difficult to manage the interest rate exposure of these positions. Unchecked, these conditions compress net interest margins, tangible book values, and other key financial ratios of the firm.
Derivatives enable financial risk managers to optimize investment and funding decisions, and client requests rather than being driven by their interest rate risk profile. Recent accounting changes and advances in analytical capabilities following CECL adoption allow executives to explore hedging strategies with greater flexibility and precision than they experienced during previous rate tightening cycles. For financial risk executives, capitalizing on this more flexible playbook is a strategic imperative.
Why in this environment?
Rising interest rates impact demand for fixed-rate financing, and the value of your institution’s fixed-rate loan and debt securities positions (bond prices fall as rates rise). More problematic for executive teams, the accounting for these valuation adjustments adversely impacts key performance metrics scrutinized by investors, even when the underlying portfolio performs as contracted.
After a long period of historically low interest rates, concerns over inflation have moderated the Federal Reserve’s accommodative monetary stance, and rates have risen in response. Increasing interest rates provide unique challenges to institutions managing the risk of fixed-rate assets, especially instruments backed by residential and commercial real estate that are characterized by dynamic prepayment and default risk. To navigate this environment successfully, institutions will need to develop a deep understanding of how these assets may behave in different market environments and consider hedging away unwanted risks.
Updated accounting for hedges
The Financial Accounting Standards Board’s (FASB) previously released updates (ASU 2017-12) that introduced the “last-of-layer” method, which enabled fair value hedges to be recognized for prepayable financial assets. Under this method, entities designate a stated amount of the asset or assets that is not expected to prepay, default, or experience other events affecting the timing and amount of cash flows, as the hedged item in a fair value hedge of interest rate risk.
Newly released Accounting Standard Update 2022-01 expands the last-of-layer model to allow designation of multiple layers in a single portfolio as individual hedged items. By allowing multiple hedging relationships with a single closed portfolio, the update enables entities to hedge a larger portion of the interest rate risk associated with a portfolio and allows more flexibility in the derivative structures available to hedge interest rate risk. The update includes provisions for new hedges to be designated, or existing hedges to be dedesignated at any time—allowing accounting to better reflect changes in an entity’s risk management activities in a dynamic interest rate environment. If a breach is anticipated (or occurs), a multi-layer strategy provides additional flexibility in determining which hedge or hedges to dedesignate.
How CECL tools help
CECL provided the incentive to advance institutions’ tools for understanding two key factors that impact hedge effectiveness: default and prepayments. Various disciplines throughout banks had some insight available to evaluate these outcomes, but CECL prompted more rigorous consideration by bringing their lifetime effects to bear on bank income statements at the inception of each loan. This financial impact enhanced the importance of understanding the interaction of macroeconomic and loan-specific information on the competition between default and prepayment risks (in a multi-period setting, raising the conditional probability of prepayment will reduce the overall or cumulative probability of default and vice versa). The resulting models integrate consideration of:
- Economic stress on loan performance
- Layers of risk (the combined effects of various factors including credit quality, loan age, combined loan to value)
- A multiperiod view (capturing time-dependent effects on default, prepayment, and recovery behavior)
These models create a richer representation of borrower behavior than was previously available to most middle market and community banks. Modeling default and prepayment processes at the loan-level (as opposed to the pool-level analysis prevalent pre-CECL) significantly improves accuracy in estimating losses, particularly for portfolios with heterogenous credit characteristics. Importantly, these models allow nuanced analysis of portfolio performance with one or multiple macroeconomic scenarios. This forward-looking, multi-scenario view enables credit teams to provide deeper insights on default and prepayment with the same scenarios used by ALM and Treasury teams to plan liquidity, investment and hedging strategies (or provide CECL model outputs directly to ALM and capital planning tools). With these additional capabilities, hedging strategies can be optimized for resilience across a range of interest rate, default, and prepayment scenarios.
For those institutions that implemented a robust CECL methodology, the insight needed to create hedge relationships is already in place. For those that did not, executives should carefully consider this broader rationale for investment. Incremental process updates can significantly impact both CECL and hedging analysis of expected portfolio performance.
How does the strategy work?
There are multiple options from a derivative perspective—all are dependent upon a clear understanding of expected behavior in the hedged item. To create effective hedge relationships, entities will need to evaluate expected prepayments and credit losses in the hedged portfolio across a range of scenarios to understand possible paths for interest rates, as well as other factors relevant to prepayment and default behavior (e.g., real estate prices, vacancy, unemployment, etc.). This analysis maximizes the precision of portfolio construction, optimizes the effectiveness of the hedge for reasonable and supportable economic conditions, and provides a recurring reference for updating risk management strategies when actual conditions vary from forecast scenarios.
Once expected behavior of the portfolio is understood, a layered hedge strategy can be developed to respond to all or part of the identified interest rate risk. Some layers may focus on moderate swings in the economy and others may be designed to be unaffected outside of economic conditions at the extremes. For example, a 3-layered hedge of a portfolio may utilize an initial layer that even in periods of sizeable economic change would not see a risk of over-hedging. A second layer could represent the difference between the extreme and expected outcome, and a final layer that would be most at risk of prepayment or credit losses. This scenario is not improbable given the current economic outlook which includes rising interest rates, inflation risk, and increasing potential for an economic downturn.
Optimizing decisions for loans and the investment portfolio, funding, and client requests is key to financial institutions’ success. It is exceptionally difficult to manage these competing priorities, especially during times of rate volatility. Derivatives are a key tool for responding to market challenges and the infrastructure to support them has evolved since the last time interest rates increased. Advances in credit analytics and favorable developments in accounting requirements position firms for a more agile response and ensure financial results reflect the benefits of risk management activities in any rate scenario.
Ben Lewis – Financial Institutions Derivatives Advisory, Managing Director & Head of Sales, Chatham Financial
Scott Dietz, Director – Financial Institution Accounting Industry Practice Lead, Moody’s Analytics
Chris Stanley, Senior Director – Banking Sector Industry Practice Lead, Moody’s Analytics
Send us a message today if you are interested in learning more about interest rate hedging.
Chatham Hedging Advisors, LLC (CHA) is a subsidiary of Chatham Financial Corp. and provides hedge advisory, accounting and execution services related to swap transactions in the United States. CHA is registered with the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) as a commodity trading advisor and is a member of the National Futures Association (NFA); however, neither the CFTC nor the NFA have passed upon the merits of participating in any advisory services offered by CHA. For further information, please visit chathamfinancial.com/legal-notices.
Transactions in over-the-counter derivatives (or “swaps”) have significant risks, including, but not limited to, substantial risk of loss. You should consult your own business, legal, tax and accounting advisers with respect to proposed swap transaction and you should refrain from entering into any swap transaction unless you have fully understood the terms and risks of the transaction, including the extent of your potential risk of loss. This material has been prepared by a sales or trading employee or agent of Chatham Hedging Advisors and could be deemed a solicitation for entering into a derivatives transaction. This material is not a research report prepared by Chatham Hedging Advisors. If you are not an experienced user of the derivatives markets, capable of making independent trading decisions, then you should not rely solely on this communication in making trading decisions. All rights reserved.22-0157
Our featured insights
Back-to-Back Swap Program Benchmark Statistics Report
Our back-to-back swap benchmark report compares customer swap transactions across years, regions, and bank asset size. While your financial institution may not yet be using swaps to win more commercial loan business, you can still find value in reviewing this report.
July NFP tops expectations, Treasury yields advance
After falling for three consecutive weeks, Treasury yields moved notably higher last week while the major U.S. equity indices ended the week mixed as investors digested hawkish comments from Federal Reserve officials, a robust July jobs report, and a packed second-quarter corporate earnings...
FOMC hikes another 75 basis points; Q2 GDP contracts
Treasury yields across the curve took another leg lower last week, the third consecutive weekly decline, as investors grappled with a weak Q2 GDP reading, a slightly-more-dovish-than-expected FOMC, and strong earnings from the biggest tech corporations.
Derivatives Market Update for Financial Institutions
We are excited to share market insights, best practices, and product enhancements from our advisory teams focused on community and regional financial institutions. Topics will include borrower swaps, balance sheet risk management, hedge accounting, and regulatory compliance, among others.
Big banks post strong Q2 earnings, yields continue decline
Treasury yields and U.S. equities rallied last week as investors digested weak economic data and prepared for the upcoming FOMC monetary policy meeting.
Curve inversion accelerates, CPI tops expectations
Treasury yields oscillated in a large band last week with the long end of the curve seeing notable declines as market participants reacted to the latest inflation data and recalibrated their expectations for FOMC policy rate moves in the coming year.
Fed minutes reiterate FOMC’s hawkish stance; June NFP surprises to the upside
Erasing the moves seen the week prior, Treasury yields continued to experience significant volatility, rising considerably across the curve, as market participants digested the latest economic data and the minutes from the June FOMC monetary policy meeting.
Navigating the turbulence of rising rates, inflation, and volatility
Ben Lewis wrote for our friends at Bank Director and highlights how financial institutions can prepare themselves for rising interest rates, inflation, and market volatility through the use of interest risk management tools.