NCUA finalizes more flexible derivatives rules
Managing Partner, Board Member
Global Head of Financial Institutions
Kennett Square, PA
The National Credit Union Administration (NCUA) Board approved the modernization of its existing derivatives rules, making them more principles-based and flexible for federal credit unions (FCUs) to manage interest rate risk. These regulatory changes remove the lengthy application process and simplify the use of common hedging tools for many FCUs.
The NCUA Board finalized many of the proposed changes to the derivatives rules, which include:
- Eliminating the pre-approval process for FCUs that are “complex” with a Management CAMEL component rating of 1 or 2
- Eliminating the specific product permissibility
- Eliminating the regulatory limits on the amount of derivatives usage
The pre-approval (or application) process for derivatives authority is discontinued for any FCU that is “complex” and has a Management CAMEL component rating of 1 or 2. The term “complex” refers to any federally insured credit union having assets greater than $500 million. For those FCUs not meeting this requirement, they will need to complete an application. However, they no longer need to obtain interim approval, reducing the overall process from up to 120 days to less than 60 days.
The new principles-based methodology broadens the parameters for permissible hedging instruments. Specifically, acceptable derivatives must have all the following characteristics: denominated in U.S. dollars, based on domestic interest rates (or dollar-denominated LIBOR), contract maturity of 15 years or less, and may not be used to create Structured Liability Offerings. Additionally, the rule change removes the limitation of a forward-start date beyond 90 days as well as the limitation on floating notional amounts.
The finalized rules also eliminate certain requirements related to the measurement and reporting of position limits, specifically the fair value loss limit and weighted average remaining maturity notional (WARMN) limit. The Board believes removing the burden of measuring and reporting these limits outweighs the potential benefits. However, the NCUA will still review derivative exposures when conducting exams and could determine excess exposures to be a safety and soundness concern.
The NCUA Board also withdrew some proposed changes to the derivatives rules which resulted in:
- Eliminating the collateral requirements for cleared derivative with deference to established clearinghouse parameters
- Eliminating the prohibition on written options provided that such options are used to manage interest rate risk
- Eliminating the requirement that all counterparties be domiciled in the United States
FCUs are still required to work with a CFTC-registered swap dealer, futures commission merchant, introducing broker or a clearing house as counterparty for any derivative transaction. A major swap participant does not meet that requirement. Additionally, FCUs may continue to use external service providers (ESPs) to support many aspects of their derivatives program. ESPs may not act as a counterparty, principal, or agent in any derivative transactions involving the FCU.
Why use derivatives
“In the years ahead, a credit union’s ability to manage interest-rate risk will play a crucial role in its financial performance,” NCUA Chairman Todd M. Harper said. “As such, this rule is a timely and appropriate measure that ensures complex federal credit unions can manage a variety of interest-rate scenarios. It also provides a way for smaller credit unions, which demonstrate proficiency and obtain regulatory approval, to use simple derivatives to hedge their loan portfolios.”
Interest rate derivatives are cost-effective tools that can be customized and quickly applied to help credit unions manage asset and liability risks, lower funding costs, and enhance margins. Over the last year, many credit unions have experienced a significant increase in member deposits, leading to excess liquidity and low-yielding cash balances. Simple hedging tools like a swap can extend asset duration in the loan or securities portfolio and improve margins while also managing exposure to higher rates.
Swaps can manage the rate risk of an individual mortgage loan or investment security. A pooled hedging approach using a similar swap structure may create even more efficiencies from a pricing and accounting perspective, especially if the underlying fixed-rate assets are prepayable. A credit union would create a closed pool of fixed-rate, prepayable mortgages or securities and hedge a portion of the pool based on a prepayment analysis. This approach is commonly referred to as a “last of layer” strategy and has become very popular given more flexible accounting rules.
A credit union can use current or forward-starting swaps to achieve the preferred mix of fixed and floating-rate exposures. The NCUA’s new derivatives rules no longer limit the forward-starting period to 90 days. A longer forward-starting period would allow credit unions to recognize the fixed-rate coupons on a pool of mortgages or securities until the swap would become effective on the future start date. At that time, the institution would have protection to help mitigate the potential impact of a rising rate environment.
How to get started
Putting together an interest rate hedging program can be intimidating and overwhelming. Many credit unions partner with an ESP like Chatham to help them build the infrastructure and provide the training needed for a successful program. The ESP should be a trusted advisor with broad experience and deep resources that can provide support throughout the lifecycle of an interest rate hedge.
Some common areas that an ESP will provide credit unions with assistance include:
- Developing a hedging policy
- Evaluating potential strategies from both an economic and accounting perspective
- Negotiating ISDA agreements with dealer counterparties
- Supporting trade execution and document review
- Providing valuations and hedge accounting
- Servicing existing trades including rate resets, payments, and collateral management
- Complying with regulatory requirements including ongoing reporting
NCUA Vice Chairman Kyle S. Hauptman shared this commentary after the new derivatives rules were finalized, “Derivatives aren’t inherently frightening. They are indeed a powerful tool, and anything that’s powerful can probably cause harm. But there’s also harm in not allowing people to use the best available tool. For example, you can try to manage interest rate risk without using derivatives, but it can be a bit like dealing with a fly on the window by throwing a brick at it. So, it’s great to see that credit unions have already demonstrated safe derivatives usage. Not to mention, it’s human nature to switch to better tools when they’re available… the same reason we don’t commute via horseback anymore.”
NCUA’s new derivatives rules provide a more principles-based approach to managing interest rate risk while maintaining a safety and soundness framework. The additional flexibility and ease of use should be well received by many FCUs currently utilizing derivatives and those considering hedging tools. Credit unions can partner with an experienced ESP for assistance with building and supporting a successful program. Note the final derivatives rules are effective 30 days after publication in the Federal Register.
This on-demand webinar reviews the NCUA’s new derivatives rules in more detail and discusses hedging strategies that credit unions can apply to manage their interest rate risk. We also identify the advantages of adding derivatives to the ALCO toolkit while also considering some challenges credit unions could face.
Founded in 1991, Chatham Financial is the world’s largest independent derivatives advisory firm, executing over $750 billion in transaction volume annually and helping clients across industries maximize their value in the capital markets. Chatham partners with credit unions throughout the U.S. to support their interest rate hedging activities. As an external service provider, we are equipped to deliver training, trade structuring, pricing execution, hedge accounting, and regulatory advisory support, among other services. Having an independent and transparent approach allows us to bring a partnership mentality to every client engagement.
Contact us to learn more about how these changes impact your credit union.
Chatham Hedging Advisors, LLC (CHA) is a subsidiary of Chatham Financial Corp. and provides hedge advisory, accounting and execution services related to swap transactions in the United States. CHA is registered with the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) as a commodity trading advisor and is a member of the National Futures Association (NFA); however, neither the CFTC nor the NFA have passed upon the merits of participating in any advisory services offered by CHA. For further information, please visit chathamfinancial.com/legal-notices.
Transactions in over-the-counter derivatives (or “swaps”) have significant risks, including, but not limited to, substantial risk of loss. You should consult your own business, legal, tax and accounting advisers with respect to proposed swap transaction and you should refrain from entering into any swap transaction unless you have fully understood the terms and risks of the transaction, including the extent of your potential risk of loss. This material has been prepared by a sales or trading employee or agent of Chatham Hedging Advisors and could be deemed a solicitation for entering into a derivatives transaction. This material is not a research report prepared by Chatham Hedging Advisors. If you are not an experienced user of the derivatives markets, capable of making independent trading decisions, then you should not rely solely on this communication in making trading decisions. All rights reserved.21-0153
Our featured insights
FOMC meeting minutes provide insight during the holiday week
The FOMC meeting minutes release headlined last week’s economic news. In the release, the Committee noted they see conditions continuing to tighten while inflation remains above their target.
Cooling markets, strengthening yen, and hopes for a soft landing
Data released this week showed that jobless claims, the U.S. industrial production, gasoline prices, and the rate of inflation have cooled off. The U.S. dollar was on track Friday for one of its steepest weekly falls against other major currencies this year, while the Japanese yen showed one of...
Powell’s hawkish turn; decline in petroleum demand brings prices down from summer highs
During a light week for economic releases, commentary from Federal Reserve leaders provided color on the path forward for interest rates. Petroleum product prices dropped to recent lows amid reduced demand and growing interest in Venezuelan oil.
Expert Conversation with Matt Henry and Rob Kaplan
Matt Henry, Chatham's Managing Partner and CEO, and Rob Kaplan, former President and CEO of the Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas, discuss the economy, alternative capital sources, interest rates, and more.
BoE holds rates steady again while ECB pauses record run of hikes
The Bank of England (BoE) kept rates on hold at 5.25% for a second consecutive meeting today, as it attempts to balance a weakening economy with inflation that is still measuring three times its target. The Bank's updated forecasts show medium-term inflation slightly higher than in August's...
Fed holds rates steady while noting tighter financial conditions
On Wednesday, November 1, 2023, the Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) voted unanimously to hold the fed funds rate at a target range of 5.25%–5.50%. Today's pause represents consecutive FOMC meetings with no rate change, having hiked in 11 out of the last 14 prior meetings. The most notable...
Capital Markets Sentiment Report
This report’s data comes from five poll questions answered during a live Chatham webinar held on September 21, 2023, hosted by Amol Dhargalkar and Jackie Bowie. We polled over 1,500 respondents spanning various industries, including commercial real estate, corporates, financial institutions, and...
Jackie Bowie and Amol Dhargalkar discuss the role of alternative capital sources in TMI treasurycast
TMI treasurycast sits down with Jackie Bowie and Amol Dhargalkar to discuss the role of alternative capital sources and the opportunities and challenges borrowers may face over traditional means. They outline how to determine if alternative funding sources are appropriate depending on the business.