LIBOR transition: practical issues for UK borrowers
Managing Partner, Board Member
Head of Europe
Real Estate | London
SummaryGBP LIBOR will lose its regulatory support at the end of 2021, and its administrator (ICE) is carrying out a consultation on its intention to cease publication of the benchmark. In this piece, we’ll cover some common issues our clients are encountering as we approach GBP LIBOR’s discontinuation.
While SONIA is the widely agreed upon replacement rate, the majority of floating-rate loans and derivatives are still indexed to LIBOR. The coming nine months are a crucial period for borrowers wishing to ensure that their financing arrangements are not adversely affected by the transition.
Almost all loan contracts linked to LIBOR will contain some fallback provisions specifying how to calculate the floating rate if LIBOR is unavailable. For a small number of bank lenders, contracts drafted more recently may explicitly specify a switch to SONIA on a defined date before the end of 2021, alongside other provisions for the new calculation of interest such as compounding conventions and determination of the credit adjustment spread (CAS – see below). Unfortunately, such contracts are a small proportion of the total.
In most cases, the loan contract will need to be amended in order to document the move from LIBOR to SONIA. The majority of loans signed since 2017 (when the FCA announced its intention to withdraw support from LIBOR) specify that LIBOR’s discontinuation will trigger negotiations between the borrower and agent aimed at agreeing on a replacement benchmark and other associated amendments required for its use. The complexity of these negotiations will vary significantly. At one end of the spectrum, agreeing amendments to a bilateral loan where the agent is also the sole lender should be relatively straightforward. Doing the same for a large group of lenders will be more challenging and time-consuming.
With an eye to the potential for long negotiation periods, many contracts signed over the last year specify that amendment discussions should start in advance of LIBOR’s actual discontinuation. April 2021 is a common choice, in a nod to the Financial Conduct Authority’s direction that UK-supervised lenders should stop signing new loans linked to GBP LIBOR by the end of Q1 2021. This allows potentially lengthy discussions around the replacement benchmark and associated amendments to be conducted while LIBOR is still available to be used for the calculation of interest.
There is also a large body of problematic contracts that do not mandate such a renegotiation until LIBOR is actually discontinued — and a significant number that do not contemplate amendments at all. Worse, such contracts frequently contain interim fallback arrangements that are unattractive or impractical, having been designed for temporary unavailability of LIBOR rather than permanent discontinuation. A common example is the specification that, in the absence of LIBOR, the agent will obtain estimates from a group of reference banks on the rate at which they would expect to borrow in the interbank market for the interest period in question. Few agents would be operationally equipped to carry out such polls for all the loans on their books even if the reference banks were willing to provide quotes.
The overall message for borrowers is that, in their current state, a high proportion of fallback arrangements in loan contracts will make the calculation of interest difficult or impossible once LIBOR is discontinued. In some cases, borrowers may also be subject to a floating rate that depends on opaque and unchallengeable calculations of the lenders’ cost of funds.
To avoid these risks, such borrowers need to proactively engage with their lenders and switch their loan contracts from LIBOR to SONIA before LIBOR’s discontinuation, and agree associated amendments to allow for interest to be calculated using the new benchmark.
Calculation of the credit adjustment spread (CAS)
Historically, SONIA has typically fixed lower than LIBOR. As a result, counterparties moving a contract from LIBOR to SONIA will also agree on a spread to be added to SONIA to compensate for this difference — the CAS.
At present, there are two approaches to calculating the CAS:
- Backward-looking: CAS is calculated as the median of the historical spread between LIBOR and compounded SONIA for the relevant interest period, using daily data from the five years leading up to the transition date.
- Forward-looking: CAS is calculated as the average difference between the forward curves for LIBOR and compounded SONIA for the relevant interest period, over the period from the transition date to the contract’s termination date.
The backward-looking approach is common in the derivatives market as it is the methodology specified in the ISDA Fallbacks Supplement. It is also widely used in the fallback arrangements for LIBOR-linked loan contracts that explicitly specify a switch to SONIA.
While the outcomes from the two approaches are expected to converge as we approach LIBOR’s discontinuation date, they will not always give the same result. At the time of writing, for three-month interest periods the forward-looking approach gave a result up to five basis points lower than the backward-looking approach, with the exact difference dependent on the contract’s termination date.
Different lenders are at very different stages in their LIBOR transition programmes. While an increasing number can provide SONIA-linked loans and derivatives (and some will now refuse to offer GBP loans linked to LIBOR), many are not yet operationally set up to do so. For those in the latter category, which includes most non-bank lenders, discussions about how to transition existing LIBOR loans over to SONIA may only be possible at a high level at present.
A third category of lender is able to offer SONIA loans and transition legacy LIBOR loans, but unable to offer some (or any) hedging products referencing SONIA. In these cases, borrowers should be particularly careful about agreeing to conventions on the loan that are difficult or impossible to mirror in the derivative market with a non-lender counterparty.
We anticipate that the FCA’s upcoming deadline for UK-supervised lenders to cease signing new loans on GBP LIBOR from 31 March 2021 will catalyse progress.
The ISDA Fallbacks Protocol — and whether to use it
Having taken effect on 25 January 2021, the ISDA Fallbacks Supplement amends the definition of GBP LIBOR in ISDAs signed after that date to include an explicit switch to compound SONIA plus a spread. It fully specifies the compounding calculation conventions involved and selects the backward-looking calculation approach for the CAS. Meanwhile, the ISDA Fallbacks Protocol allows counterparties to derivative contracts signed before 25 January 2021 to retroactively amend their contracts such that they also include the ISDA Fallbacks Supplement.
For borrowers that used derivatives to hedge their debt, it is important to highlight that adhering to the ISDA Fallbacks Protocol has no impact on the underlying loan contract — only the derivative. The compounding and other calculation conventions specified by the ISDA Fallbacks Supplement do not mirror the most common conventions emerging in loan market documentation. As a result, adhering to the ISDA Fallbacks Protocol may make it difficult for the borrower to fully mirror the terms of the loan in the derivative and maintain a fully effective hedging relationship.
Since LIBOR’s discontinuation was announced in 2017, many have understandably been waiting for market conventions to crystalise before beginning their transition programs. While there are still some uncertainties in this area, time is now running short. A proactive engagement with the issues described above is the only way for borrowers to ensure they are not exposed to unnecessary risks in nine months’ time.
Contact a LIBOR transition expert
Please send a message to the Chatham team if you have questions around the GBP LIBOR transition or how the use of SONIA in your loans and derivatives could affect your interest rate exposure.
Chatham Hedging Advisors, LLC (CHA) is a subsidiary of Chatham Financial Corp. and provides hedge advisory, accounting and execution services related to swap transactions in the United States. CHA is registered with the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) as a commodity trading advisor and is a member of the National Futures Association (NFA); however, neither the CFTC nor the NFA have passed upon the merits of participating in any advisory services offered by CHA. For further information, please visit chathamfinancial.com/legal-notices.
Transactions in over-the-counter derivatives (or “swaps”) have significant risks, including, but not limited to, substantial risk of loss. You should consult your own business, legal, tax and accounting advisers with respect to proposed swap transaction and you should refrain from entering into any swap transaction unless you have fully understood the terms and risks of the transaction, including the extent of your potential risk of loss. This material has been prepared by a sales or trading employee or agent of Chatham Hedging Advisors and could be deemed a solicitation for entering into a derivatives transaction. This material is not a research report prepared by Chatham Hedging Advisors. If you are not an experienced user of the derivatives markets, capable of making independent trading decisions, then you should not rely solely on this communication in making trading decisions. All rights reserved.21-0042
Our featured insights
Understanding recent changes in SOFR-based loan index rates
There has been a recent divergence between the different variations of SOFR used in commercial real estate (CRE) loans, with Term SOFR increasing while daily simple SOFR and New York Fed 30-Day Average SOFR remaining relatively flat prior to the Federal Reserve meeting and the other starting to...
Interest rate swap FAQs for CRE investors
These frequently asked questions address some of the common issues that commercial real estate borrowers face when considering an interest rate swap. These include swap rates and mechanics, prepayment/breakage, and documentation.
GBP LIBOR’s last days, SONIA, and the start of synthetic GBP LIBOR
With only days to go until the final GBP LIBOR fixing, below is a short update on current state of transition and the emerging discussions on use of synthetic LIBOR.
Understanding LIBOR alternatives in CRE loans
Commercial real estate (CRE) lenders have begun to adopt SOFR and other LIBOR alternatives, presenting borrowers with different variations of these rates. This overview provides a summary of the common permutations of these rates and borrower considerations for each.
Hedging costs update — November 8, 2021
The Fed has started tapering its purchase of bonds, signaling a potential end to quantitative easing (QE). This has occurred in the context of a market that has pulled forward expected timing for a rate hike from the Fed. These factors have driven a rapid increase in hedging costs, particularly...
The finish line is in sight — GBP LIBOR transition
As the date for the final GBP LIBOR fixing nears, the work from the banking and advisory community to transition all outstanding contracts from LIBOR to the new RFR is gathering momentum. We have previously published articles on the background to the transition and how borrowers should prepare....
U.S. real estate and capital markets update Q3 2021
As we wind down on summer 2021, many Americans are returning to the office and sending their children back to school. We recently reviewed the effects of COVID-19 on the U.S. economy and takeaways for the real estate market during our semiannual market update webinar. On September 15,...
European real estate and capital markets update Q3 2021
It’s back-to-school month for most children, and back to the office for an increasing number of workers too. What better time to host our semiannual market update webinar for real estate? On 15 September, participants listened to our experts, Adrian Ng and Jamie Macdonald, provide an overview of...