How to maintain treasury proficiency and continuity amid the “Great Resignation”
Chief Operating Officer
Today’s job market creates challenges and opportunities for treasury teams. While high turnover warrants increased focus on retention and contingency planning, it also offers the chance to attract new talent, reinvent your team dynamic, and streamline operations.
Treasury and accounting teams face challenges on multiple fronts in the current environment, and one trend most all are confronting is team turnover and its threat to business continuity. Viewed as a cost center, finance teams are lean to begin with. The employee-centered job market — driven by wage inflation and shifting employee expectations — compounds the issue as employees chase work-from-home arrangements and upward mobility. Like any sea change, this creates both challenges and opportunities. While high turnover and ample open positions warrant an increased focus on employee retention and contingency planning, they also offer the chance to attract new talent, reinvent your team dynamic, and streamline operations. Whether you’re in survival mode hoping to weather key-person risk or embracing the new environment as an opportunity, consider the following as you navigate the Great Resignation and Great Reshuffle.
Expect changing work profiles
While some recent workforce changes may be transitory, others may last longer as teams adopt new work profiles. Whether it’s the types of activities your team is undertaking, changes required by remote work to accomplish them, or new team dynamics driven by work-from-home flexibility, new views of what a treasury team looks like at any given organization are emerging.
Conquer immediate challenges
If team attrition or a painful adaptation to hybrid work arrangements is creating disruption, prioritize addressing the immediate challenge. This could include plugging personnel gaps, altering processes to support hybrid work, or formalizing remote work adjustments into a sustainable, repeatable model. If your organization lost key talent and seeks to fill a position, you may be forced to rethink job requirements and responsibilities. Often, this includes at least some adjustment to the new job posting versus the vacated position. This may stem from a disconnect between your operational needs and remaining, overburdened team and resources. It may force you to rethink the ideal capabilities and requirements for the role, addressing questions, such as:
- Should this be a more junior or more senior role?
- Does this job require two people instead of one?
- Can elements of this role be automated or outsourced?
Considering these issues while filling your immediate need can initiate longer-term improvements.
Proactively embrace opportunities
Whether it is thrust upon you through employee turnover or undertaken as an intentional strategy, you can proactively embrace employee turnover and view it as a chance to attract new talent. This entails being more intentional about redesigning your treasury function and work styles to align with the new reality. Instead of waiting until you lose an employee, you can start a conversation about your ideal state and what it would take to develop a proficient, sustainable team. Perhaps this means designing roles to be more strategic, more fulfilling, or offering more development opportunities. You may be able to operate in a smarter, more efficient way that leverages a smaller headcount or gives your current team more capacity to take on interesting side projects and areas of personal interest. In many cases, the role redesign process can also provide meaningful retention benefits by offering career development opportunities.
Subscribe to receive our market insights and webinar invites
Reimagine your treasury function
You can begin proactively embracing opportunities by taking these seven steps:
1. Document current processes
If your organization is like most companies, you don’t have fully documented processes in place. You may have reasonably accurate policies, but often the supporting detail at the “screenshots and operating procedures” level is outdated or non-existent. You may have some institutional knowledge supplementing existing documentation to capture the exceptions inherent in a complex treasury program, but in times of high turnover, that reliance on institutional knowledge can create meaningful key-person risk. Whatever your starting point, take a fresh look at your documentation to uncover areas where business continuity relies on processes or information that exists only in someone's head. Then, develop documentation that can facilitate the fluid transfer of roles and responsibilities within your team.
2. Benchmark against peers
Before embarking on a refreshed staffing model, review your program relative to your peers and leading industry practices. Consider leveraging an outside partner or industry peer group with visibility into the practices that organizations like yours are successfully employing.
3. Whiteboard your ideal state
Starting with a blank slate and whiteboarding your treasury organization adds value even if you don’t have the desire, budget, or buy-in for a complete overhaul. Taking the time to ask, “What would we ideally want to achieve?” can uncover the low-hanging fruit of small changes that may yield an outsized impact. You may find pockets of quick improvements, such as cross-training or process flow efficiencies, along with areas requiring more material measures, such as a system change. Mapping out your dream state is something you can undertake as a team to uncover and prioritize areas for improvement.
4. Leverage technology and automation
Redefining your treasury function often means employing technology to increase data visibility, add controls to the process, and use valuable human resources in higher value add activities. How much time does your team spend time chasing down data from different business units and coordinating internally to align on the right data snapshot for hedging?
A treasury technology platform can:
- Serve as a centralized repository where multiple users can input data, automatically monitoring your progress towards a full dataset
- Provide built-in audit trails, so you can automatically flag individuals or business units for updates — and your system chases down the data instead of you
- Enable you to set permission standards for users worldwide so everyone can access the data relevant to their roles but with appropriate controls in place to protect the aggregated data
- Enable your treasury team to review the organization’s exposure profile, approve suggested trades, and execute hedges, so you can focus more effort on strategy and less on data aggregation
Technology can increase efficiency and add controls, allowing you to utilize treasury resources more effectively and reduce human error. Importantly, consider your processes holistically. Rather than automating clunky, timeworn procedures based on current technology constraints, outline the optimal process and then consider how technology can best facilitate it.
5. Conduct cross-functional training
Documenting processes across functional roles and providing training so multiple people can complete each function provides continuity in case of key-person risk. Reacting to an employee’s two-week notice with a frantic bid to extract knowledge from one person's head and replicate it until you can backfill the position provides significant strain on the team, especially in today’s competitive hiring environment. Cross-training employees for different roles can alleviate that key-person risk while also creating development opportunities for people on your team — which can also improve job satisfaction and minimize turnover in the first place.
6. Consider temporary or permanent outsourcing:
In some cases, you may decide it makes more sense to outsource certain roles, rather than fill them internally. Functions we frequently see outsourced include trade execution, risk analysis, and repetitive operational tasks.
Trade execution: If your organization is one employee deep in its trading function, that person occasionally needs to go on vacation, leave the office, or contribute elsewhere. So, the likelihood that you can rely on one person for all trading activity and never face a scheduling conflict is low. When you add a backup person that steps in rarely, they likely can’t maintain the same institutional knowledge, market experience, and trading intuition that comes with frequent hedge execution. Even with two traders, you still face scheduling constraints and the inherent limitations of knowledge that any two individuals can possibly amass throughout their careers. That’s why it’s common for organizations to rely on a wider bench of hedging resources — accessing experts who trade all day, every day across numerous clients, which brings them more market color than any one individual seeing only their own organization’s trades.
Risk analysis: For companies conducting a periodic review of their exposure profile and hedging strategies, it can be a material draw on resources to gather data from business units and run analysis to gain insight into the risk profile versus working with a partner who has visibility into how other corporates model their risk and inform stakeholders. Leveraging proven models and scenarios can be more efficient, accurate, and impactful than building custom models, obtaining the right data sources, and determining the appropriate methodology in-house.
Temporary support: When companies are faced with extreme staffing changes, due to high turnover, spinoff, or business reorganization, many will choose to employ a temporary outsourced staffing model to maintain operations while a more optimal staffing model is designed. While this is typically more costly on an annualized basis, it can afford a company the breathing room to make more effective long-term decisions around structure and hiring.
7. Plan for ongoing policy and governance
After you’ve reimagined and implemented your risk management infrastructure, plan to review and improve it at regular intervals. Periodically conducting a comprehensive review ensures greater confidence in the program from investors, the board, senior management, and other stakeholders. As markets and business practices change, regularly reviewing and comparing your governance and policy documents against leading practices for risk management elevates the level of assurance that treasury can provide to senior management teams.
Rather than reacting to the "Great Resignation," viewing it as an opportunity to review and reimagine your treasury program can position your organization to thrive in today's high-turnover environment and beyond. Chatham can partner with you throughout the process, whether it's providing continuity after an employee departure, conducting process documentation and policy review, or streamlining your program with financial risk management technology. Contact your relationship manager or complete the form below to get started.
Chatham Financial corporate treasury advisory
Chatham Financial partners with corporate treasury teams to develop and execute financial risk management strategies that align with your organization’s objectives. Our full range of services includes risk management strategy development, risk quantification, exposure management (interest rate, currency, and commodity), outsourced execution, technology solutions, and hedge accounting. We work with treasury teams to develop, evaluate and enhance their risk management programs and to articulate the costs and benefits of strategic decisions.
Need to plan for challenges in your treasury program?
Complete this form to schedule a call with a treasury advisor.
Chatham Hedging Advisors, LLC (CHA) is a subsidiary of Chatham Financial Corp. and provides hedge advisory, accounting and execution services related to swap transactions in the United States. CHA is registered with the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) as a commodity trading advisor and is a member of the National Futures Association (NFA); however, neither the CFTC nor the NFA have passed upon the merits of participating in any advisory services offered by CHA. For further information, please visit chathamfinancial.com/legal-notices.
Transactions in over-the-counter derivatives (or “swaps”) have significant risks, including, but not limited to, substantial risk of loss. You should consult your own business, legal, tax and accounting advisers with respect to proposed swap transaction and you should refrain from entering into any swap transaction unless you have fully understood the terms and risks of the transaction, including the extent of your potential risk of loss. This material has been prepared by a sales or trading employee or agent of Chatham Hedging Advisors and could be deemed a solicitation for entering into a derivatives transaction. This material is not a research report prepared by Chatham Hedging Advisors. If you are not an experienced user of the derivatives markets, capable of making independent trading decisions, then you should not rely solely on this communication in making trading decisions. All rights reserved.22-0102
Our featured insights
2023 corporate treasury trends
Corporate treasury and accounting teams face a daunting list of concerns as they plan for 2023. Inflation at multi-decade highs, a war in Europe for the first time in 75 years, global central bank tightening, a roller coaster ride in on equity prices, and recession fears all pose challenges to...
7 ways to maximize FX and commodity hedging impact while minimizing costs
Hedge program costs can range from forward points, to trading costs, to fixed and variable operational costs that include systems and personnel. Program benefits often include risk reduction, operational ease, and favorable accounting treatment. This article will address leading practices and...
The state of financial risk management
This independent study of 1,100+ U.S. public companies examines their risk exposures, hedging, capital markets activity, and hedge accounting practices. Request the report to see your debt and hedging practices compared with your peers.
Chatham Financial upgrades ChathamDirect to support more adaptable financial risk management programs for treasury teams
Major additions include the industry’s first AI-powered Interest Rate Swap Loader and pre-built connectors for ERPs, TMS, and trading platforms to give true straight-through processing to every system utilized in treasury
Video | ChathamDirect technology explained in 90 seconds
To navigate a complex, ever-changing economic landscape and protect more of your bottom-line earnings, your financial risk management system should support all your program objectives. Learn how you can streamline your process and unlock new economic strategies with ChathamDirect.
Chatham Financial announces CEO transition effective January 2022
Matt Henry named the next Chatham CEO
Amol Dhargalkar: 30 years of listening and exceeding client expectations
Amol Dhargalkar discusses how Chatham has worked alongside our corporate clients to understand and exceed their expectations. Chatham Financial is celebrating 30 years of serving our clients.
Clark Maxwell and Laura Grant: 30 years of bringing knowledge, data, and tools to the capital markets
Clark Maxwell and Laura Grant talk about how Chatham continues to bring a combination of knowledge, data, and tools to the capital markets. Chatham Financial is celebrating 30 years of serving our clients.