Refinancing Canadian renewables projects post PPAs
Hedging and Capital Markets
Infrastructure | Toronto
SummaryChatham's Hugh Sutcliffe highlights the pitfalls and advantages that financial sponsors face when considering a refinancing of their renewable energy assets.
Chatham’s involvement in renewable power development in Canada coincided with the creation of the Ontario Feed-in-Tariff (FIT) program. FIT was instituted to encourage development of onshore wind, solar and other renewable projects. At the time, the Independent Electricity System Operator (IESO) offered 20-30 year fixed priced Power Purchase Agreements (PPAs) to developers. Investors were attracted by the long-dated income streams from these projects, their superior IRRs relative to bonds and low correlation with publicly traded equity returns.
By 2016, the IESO ceased to accept PPA applications, and combined with a newly elected Ontario government, new long dated PPAs were no longer issued. Not surprisingly, since then existing renewable projects have become “bid” in secondary, especially those projects that reached operating phase around two or three years post construction. With fixed revenue streams and funding locked in for an equivalent term via bank floating rate swapped to fixed rate, infrastructure funds and pension funds have been purchasing these assets at IRRs that are, while still superior to traditional fixed income alternatives, below those internal rates of return (IRRs) realised by developers. Typically, investors refinance by either, reducing bank loan credit spreads and extending the term of the loan or accessing the now well-developed market for Canadian dollar fixed rate project finance bonds. In either case these investors have succeeded in reducing their long dated funding costs and increased their IRR.
Since 2016, Chatham has advised on over $4.5B of successful renewable power refinancing’s with numerous infrastructure sponsors in Canada. As our case studies below demonstrate, these restructurings typically fall into two broad categories:
1. Bank loan refinancings of existing floating rate bank debt with legacy interest rate swaps
Chatham was mandated to assist a Canadian infrastructure sponsor in increasing a $650M bank facility by $350M (to $1B) and to extend the term by three years. Our engagement involved:
- Novating existing swaps (with a significant mark to market (MTM) outstanding) from four exiting banks to eight remaining banks. To achieve best pricing for our client, we performed extensive x-value adjustment (XVA) analysis to ensure the swap credit spread charged by the remaining banks to accept novation was consistent with Basel 3/XVA “market” pricing.
- Extending the Mandatory Early Termination (MET) date of the existing swaps to match the amended loan maturity date. As above, Chatham ensured that the client was not a ‘price taker’, since the extended swap exposure profile provided the banks with an opportunity to inflate pricing due to the non-transparent nature of XVA modelling.
- Managing the execution of new hedges due to the upsizing of the bank credit facility. Chatham selected the most appropriate bank to execute the hedges (execution bank) and negotiated swap credit spreads with the remaining assignee banks.
2. Bond refinancing of existing floating rate bank debt with legacy interest rate swaps
In the past four years a market has developed in Canada for long dated fixed rate project finance bonds. This is typically accessed as a funding vehicle once a project is well into its operational phase and is generating consistent revenues.
In a recent transaction, a Canadian sponsor was refinancing a $450M floating rate bank loan with a fixed rate bond issue. Interest rate swaps were in place with a remaining term of 18 years and a MTM liability of $90M. Due to the Additional Termination Events (ATE) in the ISDA the swap liability would need to be repaid simultaneous with loan repayment, therefore the bond issue raise was $540M. Chatham achieved an optimal solution for the settlement of the MTM liability that arose as part of the fixed rate bond issue.
The sponsor faced the following problems, which should be kept in mind by other sponsors looking to achieve a similar refinancing:
- Appointment of a bank as Reverse Swap Syndication Agent, to ensure that the government of Canada (GoC) yields used to calculate the swap termination amounts were consistent with the GoC yields used to price the new bond issue.
- Running a benchmarking exercise with each exiting bank to ensure termination values were based on appropriate bilateral credit support annex (CSA) adjustments.
- Challenging the exiting banks on provisions in the 2002 ISDA Agreement related to any benefit that a bank may receive in the event of swap termination and amounts owed by a less credit worth counterparty (see ISDA Close Out Protocol).
Often, financial sponsors don’t have the in-house derivative execution and XVA modelling capabilities to verify bank pricing. Chatham has this expertise together with the experience and technology to ensure pricing is ‘on market’.
We forecast continued robust refinancing activity in the Canadian renewables sector as infrastructure sponsors pursue a lift in IRR from their existing projects.
Contact the author
Please complete the form below to find out more about the topics discussed in this article.
This material has been created by Chatham Financial Europe, Ltd. and is intended for a non-U.S. audience. Chatham Financial Europe, Ltd. is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority of the United Kingdom with reference number 197251.
Our featured insights
Chatham Financial announces CEO transition effective January 2022
Matt Henry named the next Chatham CEO
Clark Maxwell and Laura Grant: 30 years of bringing knowledge, data, and tools to the capital markets
Clark Maxwell and Laura Grant talk about how Chatham continues to bring a combination of knowledge, data, and tools to the capital markets. Chatham Financial is celebrating 30 years of serving our clients.
Chatham Financial wins Hedging Adviser of the Year at the Risk Awards
On November 26, Chatham Financial accepted the inaugural Hedging Adviser of the Year award at the 2020 Risk Awards. This new award recognizes excellence in providing independent advice to derivatives users.
Chatham crowned Risk Management Advisory Firm of the Year
JCRA, now part of Chatham Financial, the independent financial risk management advisory, is delighted to announce that it has been recognised as Risk Management Advisory Firm of the Year at the GlobalCapital Global Derivatives Awards 2019.
This white paper reports and analyses the key UK real estate debt market trends over last 24 months up to June 2019.
The rise of energy from waste
Chatham managing director Rishin Patel comments on the rise in energy from waste opportunities and what this means for ESG investors, in GLIO journal.
Refinancing projects and pre-hedging financial market risks
Chatham's Rishin Patel comments on investment and hedging trends in the project finance and renewable energy sectors. This article was first published in GLIO Journal issue 5.